View
The New Dictionary of Hiring

Proof Problem

/PROOF PROB-LUHM/
  NOUN

A Proof Problem is a situation in which an employer makes appealing promises but gives candidates too little evidence to believe them.

MEANING

You say people advance quickly. Show me who did. You say junior employees have a voice. Show me a decision they changed. You say the work matters. Show me what happened because someone did it.

‍

Calling a claim “authentic” doesn't make it believable. A Proof Problem needs receipts: examples a candidate can inspect, question and recognize as real. You don't solve it by making the claim louder.

Defined by:
James Ellis,
Employer Brand Labs
Category:
Choice
The New Dictionary of Hiring card: Proof Problem, noun. A situation in which an employer makes appealing promises but gives candidates too little evidence to believe them. Abstract iridescent glass shape on a white background.

MAKE THE CHANGE

Instead of:
Polishing claims nobody has reason to believe.
Ask:
What evidence would make this promise credible?

EXAMPLE

A company promises rapid growth, but nobody can name a recent employee who actually advanced. Candidates have heard the claim before and keep asking the same skeptical questions.

HOW TO USE IT

Identify the claims candidates seem least willing to believe. Collect specific examples, people and outcomes that can prove those claims, then put the evidence where decisions are being made.

SAY IT TO LEADERSHIP

We're making promises that the people we need have no good reason to believe. Before we spend more making those promises louder, let's collect evidence that makes them credible.

NOT TO BE CONFUSED WITH

Choice Problem: a Proof Problem is one cause of a Choice Problem. People don't choose you because they don't believe what you say.
More from
James Ellis
Subscribe
Weekly insights